If we exclude vegetable prices, CPI inflation remains in RBI’s range: UBI research

Deepak Kumar August 29, 2023

India’s Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation has been a critical metric for the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in shaping its monetary policy. As inflation impacts everything from consumer purchasing power to the overall economic stability, managing it within a reasonable range has been one of the central objectives of the RBI. Recently, a report by Union Bank of India (UBI) has suggested that if vegetable prices are excluded from the CPI data, inflation in India remains comfortably within the RBI’s target range of 2% to 6%. This analysis brings attention to the fact that vegetable price fluctuations, which have historically been volatile, can significantly skew inflation figures, making it appear more concerning than it is in reality. By excluding these volatile price movements, a more accurate reflection of the underlying inflationary pressures in the economy emerges. The CPI is a key economic indicator that tracks changes in the prices of a basket of goods and services commonly purchased by households, including food, transportation, housing, clothing, and medical services. It is often used by central banks, including the RBI, to monitor inflation and guide decisions about interest rates. The RBI aims to keep inflation within a target range of 2% to 6%, as mandated by the Indian government. A sustained inflation rate above this range can erode purchasing power, discourage savings, and potentially harm economic growth, while inflation that is too low could signal weak demand and economic stagnation. Inflation is typically divided into two categories: core inflation and headline inflation. Core inflation excludes volatile items such as food and energy prices, which are susceptible to seasonal and geopolitical fluctuations. Headline inflation, on the other hand, includes all items, which can make it more volatile and subject to sharp movements. The UBI research report emphasizes the importance of understanding the difference between these two measures and argues that focusing on core inflation provides a more accurate assessment of underlying price trends in the economy. Vegetables, particularly staples like onions, tomatoes, and potatoes, have a significant weight in India’s CPI basket. This weight varies seasonally as agricultural production and supply chain disruptions impact the prices of these goods. The prices of vegetables can fluctuate dramatically due to factors such as weather conditions, crop failures, transportation bottlenecks, and even speculation. For instance, a shortage of onions due to poor harvests can lead to a sharp rise in their price, which directly increases CPI inflation in the short term. However, such price changes are often temporary and do not necessarily reflect the long-term inflationary trends in the economy. As a result, excluding volatile food items like vegetables from the CPI calculation can provide a clearer picture of inflation’s more persistent components, such as housing costs, wages, and energy prices. The UBI report highlights that when vegetable prices are removed from CPI data, inflation remains well within the RBI’s comfort zone. This suggests that the broader economic forces driving inflation are less severe than the headline CPI might imply. The seasonal nature of food prices, particularly for perishables like vegetables, can create sharp but short-lived spikes in inflation. For example, during the monsoon season, supply disruptions can cause prices of vegetables to rise significantly. Conversely, when the harvest is abundant and supply chains are stable, prices can drop, leading to deflationary pressures. These cyclical movements can cause large fluctuations in the monthly CPI numbers, but they do not always reflect the underlying trajectory of inflation. By excluding vegetables, analysts can remove a source of noise in the inflation data and focus on the more stable components of the economy.

Moreover, the government and central bank often take steps to mitigate the impact of such price shocks. For example, they may intervene in markets through buffer stock policies or regulate exports to stabilize prices. These measures are aimed at preventing short-term volatility from distorting long-term economic policy decisions. However, they cannot always fully smooth out the fluctuations in vegetable prices, which continue to be a major contributor to headline inflation. Core inflation, which excludes food and fuel prices, is a more stable and reliable measure for guiding monetary policy. It reflects the underlying demand and supply dynamics in the economy and is less affected by temporary price shocks. In India, core inflation has generally been more subdued than headline inflation, and this is why the RBI focuses on core inflation when making decisions about interest rates and other monetary measures. The exclusion of vegetable prices from CPI data has broader implications for how the RBI conducts monetary policy. The central bank uses interest rates as its primary tool to control inflation. When inflation is above the target range, the RBI may raise interest rates to cool down the economy, reduce demand, and bring inflation back in line with its goals. Conversely, if inflation is below the target, the RBI may lower interest rates to stimulate demand and encourage spending. However, using headline CPI as the sole guide for policy can lead to erratic decisions, as sharp movements in vegetable prices can distort the true picture of inflation. By focusing on core inflation and excluding volatile components like vegetables, the RBI can make more informed and stable decisions about interest rates, which in turn can help ensure economic stability. The UBI research thus advocates for a more nuanced approach to inflation measurement that allows for a more targeted policy response. The UBI report provides an important perspective on India’s inflation dynamics, highlighting the role that volatile vegetable prices play in distorting the headline CPI numbers. By excluding these fluctuations, the report suggests that underlying inflation remains within the RBI’s target range, signaling that the economy is not experiencing excessive price pressures. This insight has significant implications for monetary policy, as it suggests that the RBI can continue its accommodative stance without being overly concerned about temporary price hikes in food items like vegetables. Ultimately, understanding the true drivers of inflation, rather than reacting to temporary spikes in certain sectors, is critical for both policymakers.

The post If we exclude vegetable prices, CPI inflation remains in RBI’s range: UBI research first appeared on InfluencersPro.